Pushing Back Against “Pushing Back”

Evelyn Hockstein/ Reuters

“Republicans push back against critical race theory”, says the headline. Another says that “parents push back” against it. And the accompanying photos often show “parents” (or at least putative adults) making raucous asses of themselves at school board meetings.

You’d think they were protesting because their kids were being forced to eat organic vegetables in the cafeteria or something. But instead, what they were protesting was their kids being exposed to the blunt truth that there is a great deal of racism in America’s past. Those making a stink about CRT are either ignorant of what it really means, or just want to whitewash racism. Or both. In other words, while the use of the expression “pushing back” makes it sound as if people are on the defensive against some odious assault, that isn’t the case at all.

It’s an expression you hear quite a bit these days. And the great majority of the time, you will hear it applied in a disingenuous manner. The 45th W.H.O. and his sycophants were said to “push back” against “fake news” and a dishonest media. In reality, they were peddling fake news and lies, and attacking honest and decent journalists just trying to do their jobs. Republicans supposedly have been “pushing back” against election fraud. But in reality, they’re falling flat on their faces, because they’re pushing against nothing.

The metaphor of “pushing back” seems to have originated from the scenario of a bully pushing someone on the schoolyard. But more often than not, you’ll probably find that those who are reported to be pushing “back” are just pushing — it is they who are the bullies. And the media are helping them to portray themselves as victims.

Even the progressive Maddow Blog took the bait, speaking of a Republican “pushback against door-to-door vaccine outreach”. What they meant to say, of course, is that Republicans are launching a full-throttle batshit campaign of disinformation and hysteria about the Biden administration’s vaccine policies.

It was once, no doubt, a perfectly useful phrase; but as with so many other perfectly useful phrases, the right-wing propagandists co-opted it and distorted it to mean just the opposite of what it originally did — and the media were quite complicit in the deception. Think about the long list of terms that already have fallen victim to this Orwellian massacre. “Politically Correct”. “Social justice”. “Woke”. “Fake news”. “Election integrity”. “Radical”. And, lest we forget, “liberal”. Among others.

Whenever you hear the media use “pushing back” in the manner that right-wingers demand, you’d be doing society a service if you took a notion to let them know that it’s not an appropriate or accurate application. At the rate we’re going, it’s only a matter of time before the English language runs out of expressions that are still being used properly.

One comment

  1. POP!

    This is a short but wonderful take down of the Critical race theory madness!

    A while ago I sent a letter to the opinion page of one of our local newspapers, in which I asserted that neither Biden or Democrat’s in general, support the defunding of police, or the teaching of CRT in K-12 schools. But the editor asked me to provide proof that Biden does to support it. I included info from a number of websites I found online and thought I succeeded in answering that question quite well, but I have not yet received any answers to some of them. However, let me post the final and short email I sent to him tonight:

    Two questions Chuck,
    7/10/2021

    Chuck, there are just two questions you should ask yourself. First, “If CRT is not a defined doctrine and isn’t even taught in K-12 school (as Politifact determined), why then would Biden agree that something that does not exist should be taught in our public K-12 schools?

    And second, How can you base your decision to delete what I said about Biden, based on reasoning which holds that, if there is no evidence that Biden took (any) stand on CRT, that probably means he must have (at times), supported it?

    Sincerely, Pete

    I am glad that you posted this article POP since its something i have been trying to criticize on Twitter and other website. Thank you for reveling the BS being hidden in plain sight once again. You are exactly right when you say that, “But more often than not, you’ll probably find that those who are reported to be pushing ‘back’ are just pushing–It is they who are the bullies, and the media is helping them tp portray themselves as victims.”

    Many of us are getting sick and tired of their political circus, but being detached and complacent is not enough! We need to pull down the pants of the GOP and show the public that they have no moral gonads, and don’t even care about shame.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s